Health Care Proxy in NY: A Guide for Aging Parents

Health Care Proxy in NY: A Guide for Aging Parents

Short answer: A health care proxy in New York is a simple signed form that lets your parent (or you) name a trusted person, called a health care agent, to make medical decisions if they can no longer decide for themselves. It must be signed in front of two adult witnesses, and the person named as agent can't be one of them. Without one, New York law picks a decision-maker from a fixed list, which may not be the person your parent would have chosen.

Many adult children first hear about health care proxies in a hospital hallway. The better time to sort this out is now, while your parent can still say what they want. If you'd like help putting the right documents in place for your parents or yourself, you can book a call with our team.

What is a health care proxy in New York?

According to the New York State Department of Health, a health care proxy is the document you use to appoint your health care agent, someone you trust to make health care decisions for you if you become unable to make your own. The Department recommends that every adult have one and update it after major life events.

The agent's authority generally begins only after the attending practitioner determines that the person lacks the capacity to make health care decisions. Until then, your parent keeps making their own choices. The proxy can give the agent authority over all health care decisions or only some, and it can include specific instructions. One detail matters for aging parents: under New York law, an agent generally can't make decisions about artificial nutrition and hydration (feeding tubes) unless the agent reasonably knows the person's wishes on that subject, so it is worth discussing and writing those wishes down.

How do I become a health care proxy for my elderly parent?

Your parent has to make the choice; an adult child can't sign a proxy on a parent's behalf. The basic steps are:

  1. Talk first. Ask what matters most to your parent about quality of life, comfort care and life-sustaining treatment. Our post on difficult conversations with aging parents has ideas for starting that talk.

  2. Confirm capacity. Your parent must understand what they're signing. If memory is starting to slip, don't wait.

  3. Complete the form. New York provides a statutory health care proxy form. Your parent names a primary agent and, ideally, an alternate.

  4. Sign with two adult witnesses. Per the Department of Health, anyone over 18 can witness except the person being appointed as agent. Notarization isn't required in New York.

  5. Share copies. Give copies to the agent, the alternate, your parent's doctors and the hospital or care facility, and keep one where it can be found quickly.

If several siblings are involved, your parent names one agent at a time, plus alternates in order, which can help avoid arguments later.

Health care proxy vs power of attorney in New York: what's the difference?

These two documents are often confused, but they do different jobs:

  • A health care proxy covers medical decisions: treatment, surgery, hospice, and access to medical information needed to decide.

  • A durable power of attorney covers money and property: paying bills, managing bank accounts, filing taxes and handling real estate. The New York statutory short form power of attorney does not cover medical decisions.

Most aging parents need both, along with a will and often a revocable living trust. Banks can be strict about older or homemade power of attorney forms, which we cover in why banks say no to a power of attorney.

Is a living will the same as a health care proxy in New York?

No. A living will is a written statement of specific treatment wishes, while a proxy names a person to decide. The Department of Health notes that New York does not have a standard living will form, but recognizes living wills that provide "clear and convincing evidence" of a person's wishes. Many families use both: the living will states the wishes, and the agent carries them out.

Who makes medical decisions if there is no health care proxy in NY?

If your parent loses capacity without a proxy, New York's Family Health Care Decisions Act sets a priority list of surrogates for decisions in hospitals, nursing homes and hospice. Per the Department of Health and Public Health Law § 2994-d, after a court-appointed guardian (if one has authority), the order is:

  1. A spouse (if not legally separated) or domestic partner

  2. An adult son or daughter

  3. A parent

  4. An adult brother or sister

  5. A close friend

That sounds orderly, but a second spouse and adult children may disagree, or the child the hospital reaches first may not be the one your parent trusted most. A surrogate also only handles medical decisions. If your parent hasn't signed a power of attorney either, the family may need to ask a court to appoint a guardian under Article 81 of the Mental Hygiene Law to manage finances, which takes time and money and puts a judge in the middle of family decisions.

What about New Jersey families?

In New Jersey, the equivalent document is a proxy directive, part of an advance directive, which names a "health care representative." Under N.J.S.A. 26:2H-56, it must be signed and dated in front of two adult witnesses, or acknowledged before a notary public, attorney or other person authorized to administer oaths. The health care representative can't serve as a witness. The New Jersey Department of Health explains that the representative can make decisions only after a physician determines the patient is unable to make them.

If your parents spend part of the year in each state, or live in New Jersey while you live in New York, it's worth having an attorney confirm the documents will be accepted where your parents actually receive care.

A quick checklist for adult children

  • Does each parent have a signed health care proxy (NY) or proxy directive (NJ) naming an agent and an alternate?

  • Do the agents know where the originals are, and do the doctors have copies?

  • Has each parent written down wishes on life-sustaining treatment and feeding tubes?

  • Is there a current durable power of attorney for finances?

  • Is there a will or revocable living trust, and are beneficiary designations up to date?

If you're also raising children of your own, review your own documents at the same time, including how to name a guardian for your child in New York. Our estate planning page outlines the full set of documents most families consider.

Frequently asked questions

What is a health care proxy in New York?

It's a document that lets an adult appoint a health care agent to make medical decisions if they lose the ability to decide for themselves. It must be signed in front of two adult witnesses, and the agent can't be a witness.

How do I become a health care proxy for my elderly parent?

Your parent must name you on a New York health care proxy form while they still have capacity, and sign it in front of two adult witnesses other than you. Ask for a copy and give one to their doctors.

Does a health care proxy need to be notarized in New York?

No. New York requires two adult witnesses, not a notary. New Jersey allows either two adult witnesses or an acknowledgment before a notary, attorney or other authorized person.

Who makes medical decisions if there is no health care proxy in NY?

In a hospital, nursing home or hospice, a surrogate is generally chosen from the list in the Family Health Care Decisions Act: a spouse or domestic partner, then an adult child, a parent, an adult sibling, and a close friend, after any court-appointed guardian with health care authority.

Is a health care proxy the same as a power of attorney?

No. A health care proxy covers medical decisions. A durable power of attorney covers financial and property matters. Most people need both.

Plan ahead together

A health care proxy takes little time to sign and can spare your family from guessing in a crisis. To review your parents' documents, or your own, book a call with our team or call us at (877) 728-6256.

Adelman Bodner Law Firm PLLC, 271 Madison Ave, Floor 18, New York, NY 10016, (877) 728-6256, info@adelmanbodner.com. Responsible attorneys: James Adelman (NJ); Frederick Bodner and James Adelman (NY).

Attorney Advertising. This post is general information, not legal advice.

Follow Adelman Bodner Law: Facebook | Facebook Group | LinkedIn | X | YouTube | Reddit | Instagram

Previous
Previous

Chosen Family Estate Planning in NY: Who Inherits?

Next
Next

What Happens to Your Business When You Die in NY?